In this assignment, you should provide 1-2 PAGES of feedback for the paper that your group is assigned to review. Your PDF can be either single- or double-spaced depending on the amount of feedback your group has collectively. While you want to be respectful to your classmates, you would also want to be critical in constructive ways. In general, the content of a peer review can often consist of three parts:
Part I: Describe the overall content of the paper which you are reviewing. In other words, you should try to summarize what is in the draft that you are reviewing.
Part II: Evaluate the overall quality of the paper, which includes both strengths and weaknesses. You could use the grading criteria for the final paper as a base to evaluate the paper you are reading. Specifically, your review should attempt to address whether this draft does what it needs to do.
Part III: Suggest improvements in conjunction with weaknesses that you have identified. You should offer 3 to 5 specific suggestions on how this draft could be further improved.
